Some of you may have noticed, reading through these posts, that I usually drop the particle when I write about Grouchy, or Gouges. This is why:
French aristocratic names often contain a particle, 'de', 'du', des' or 'd''. This usually indicates the physical place their ancestors were given to lord over. For instance, the castle Sophie de Grouchy purchased for her daughter was called 'Le Bignon-Mirabeau' and had originally belonged to the family of the famous politician, Honoré Gabriel Riqueti, Comte de Mirabeau. The castle where Sophie de Grouchy was born does not bear her family's name, but there is a village, nearby, which does.
Some families used a particle without being members of the aristocracy. The leader of the terror was Maximilien de Robespierre, despite his thoroughly bourgeois origins.
Some individuals simply took up the particle when they wanted to mix with the nobility. Marie Gouze, for instance, became first Marie Aubry, when she married, and upon her arrival in Paris, she adopted her mother's first name, changed the spelling of her family name, and added the particle, thus becoming Olimpe de Gouges. Note that while we write her name as Olympe, she signed herself Olimpe. Also, the change from Gouzes to Gouges is probably nothing more than an alternate spelling.
One issue that non-francophone readers encounter is what to do with the particle when naming someone who used it. The good thing is that there are rules about this so you need not flounder.
Another good thing is that most names have been used accurately for generations, and that it's harder to make mistakes. No-one writes about 'de Condorcet' or the 'Marquis_Condorcet'. The correct usage is to drop the particle when only the last name is used, and to keep it when the last name is preceded with a first name or title.
So we say Mirabeau, but the Comte de Mirabeau. Of course it's more complicated than that – more later.
It's great that we don't make mistakes when naming people we are familiar with. But very often, that will be mostly men. When an Anglophone academic wants to talk about a particled woman of the past, mistakes will happen: de Beauvoir, anyone?
So here is a little primer, with examples of women's names, to help you find the correct appellation for your favorite philosophers.
(See this link for a full account in French )
So: when should you use the particle?
1) Always if the last name is precede by a title or first name:
Madame de Sévigné, Simone de Beauvoir (but note that when only their last names are used, they become Sévigné and Beauvoir).
When the last name is used by itself:
2) No, if the last name starts with a consonant, or an aspirate h, and has more than one pronounced syllable:
Grouchy, Pizan (although some Medievalists would suggest we call Christine de Pizan, 'Christine' others argue we should use her last name) .
3) No, if the name starts with an article that does not change with the particle. De+L', or De+La
The epicurean philosopher Ninon de Lenclos, was also known as L'Enclos.
4) Yes, if the name starts with an article that does change with the particle. De+Le = Du, De+Les = Des.
So if one's nobility belonged to a place linked to a little castle, such as was the case for Emilie Du Châtelet's husband, then the name would be Du Châtelet.
5) Yes, if the name has one pronounced syllable
(with the exception of a few famous people who became known by their last names only, such as Sade).
Madame De Staël, because her name is pronounced as two vowels, is Staël. But her great niece, Louise de Broglie would have been De Broglie because 'Broglie' is pronounced 'Breuil'. 'Gouges should have been De Gouges, expect that as her particle was of dubious origins, she was also simply Gouges.
6) Yes, if the last name starts with a vowel or a non-aspirate h:
And sometimes, as is the case for Anne Dacier, who translated Homer into French, the particle becomes part of the name.
I'm hoping you're not more confused than when you started! As always in French, there are exceptions, and as often in French, it's hard to find out what they are (And of course, it's all different for particles in other languages).
Leave a Reply.
This is where I live blog about my new book project, an intellectual biography of three French Revolutionary women philosophers.