Sandrine Berges
  • Home
  • Research
  • Interviews
  • Events
    • Bridging the Gender Gap Through Time
    • Wollapalooza
    • Wollstonecraft at Bilkent
  • Liberty in thy name!
  • Feminist History of Philosophy
  • Philosophical zombie fiction
  • Teaching
  • Crafts and things

Liberty, in Thy Name!
Three Women of the French Revolution: Olympe de Gouges, Manon Roland and Sophie de Grouchy

A note on the torment of the guillotine

1/23/2018

0 Comments

 
During a recent visit to the Conciergerie, I picked up a prettily bound book, entitled Note sur le supplice de la guillotine. The book contained a short essay of that title by Cabanis, five drawings by the artist Cueco, and a discussion of the moral and political philosophy of the guillotine by French philosopher Yannick Beaubatie.
​
​ 
Picture
For the main part, Cabanis's article, written 1799 (an IV) argues against recent articles that claimed that the torment of the guillotine ought to be abolished because it cannot be proven that the guillotined do not feel pain. The articles (by members of the medical profession, Cabanis's own colleagues), cite as evidence witnesses's reports of decapitated heads moving in such a way as to suggest that they responded to the situation, and attempted to communicate. One example they cite is that of Charlotte Corday, whose decapitated head was slapped by one of Sanson's valets, after which it apparently reddened as if in shame and indignation. Cabanis answers that while he was not present at any decapitation (as he did not have the stomach for it) he was present at the testing of the machine and certifies that death must be instanteanous. He then goes on to discuss the philosophical question of where pain resides, and the medical phenomenon of bodily movement after death. 

Picture

​At the end of the essay, Cabanis offers his moral and political reflections: the death penalty, he claims, ought to be abolished. But if it is not, the guillotine has to go. Not because it causes pain to its victim, but because it is too swift so that as a performance of a punishment it cannot serve its rightful purposes. Beaubatie takes this up in a fascinating discussion. In particular, he notes a resemblance between Cabanis' s reservations about the guillotine and Beccaria's utilitarian theory of punishment. Beaubatie notes further that Beccaria and Cabanis both frequented the Helvetius home, although two years apart.

What Beaubatie does not note, however is the strong resemblance between Cabanis's thought and that of his sister in law and long term friend and collaborator Sophie de Grouchy. Cabanis's principal reason for thinking that the guillotine should not be used is not - as Beaubatie claims - that it cannot serve as an exemple or detterrent, but that it does not allow enough time for spectators to react emotionally in such a way that would help their sympathy grow.
​The guillotine’s work is done in less than a minute.
The head disappears and the body is put away immediately in a basket. The spectators do not see anything; there is no tragedy; no time for emotion. All they see is the blood flow. If they draw any lesson from it, it is only to harden themselves to draw blood with less repugnance, when they are prey to furious passions. Instead of that, our institutions and all our public acts should nurture that most precious of sentiment of the human heart, compassion for the suffering and destruction of our kind. 

That it did not occur to Beaubatie, in his commentary written in 2002, to look to his long term philosophical correspondent Sophie de Grouchy for influence, as well as to Beccaria (whose path with Cabanis crossed, but two years apart) is a sign of how much work has been done over the last fifteen years in recovering the works and influence of women philosophers. 
0 Comments



Leave a Reply.

    About

    This is where I live blog about my new book project, an intellectual biography of three French Revolutionary women philosophers.

    Categories

    All
    1789
    1793
    Abolitionism
    Biography
    Bonheur Primitif
    Cabanis
    Champ De Mars Massacre
    Charity
    Charlotte Corday
    Childhood
    Conciergerie
    Condorcet
    Declaration Of The Rights Of Man
    Dumont
    Education
    Eon
    Gender
    Germaine De Stael
    Ghostwriting
    Guillotine
    Helvetius
    HIstorians
    Journalism
    Les Trois Urnes
    Letters
    Letters On Sympathy
    Manon Roland
    Mary Shelley
    Memoir
    Olympe De Gouges
    Painting
    Paris
    Pregnancy
    Prison
    Roland
    Rousseau
    Salons
    September Massacres
    Sexism
    Sophie De Grouchy
    Terror
    Theatre
    The Great Fear
    Translation
    Trial
    Wollstonecraft

    Archives

    February 2018
    January 2018
    December 2017
    November 2017
    October 2017
    September 2017
    August 2017
    July 2017
    June 2017
    May 2017
    April 2017
    March 2017

    RSS Feed

Proudly powered by Weebly
  • Home
  • Research
  • Interviews
  • Events
    • Bridging the Gender Gap Through Time
    • Wollapalooza
    • Wollstonecraft at Bilkent
  • Liberty in thy name!
  • Feminist History of Philosophy
  • Philosophical zombie fiction
  • Teaching
  • Crafts and things
✕